Coastal interior with an arched iron-grille window, walnut bench, and ajar glazed door opening onto a leafy garden.

The Cottage Coming Down on Marine Avenue

Walk the two blocks of Marine Avenue this month and you'll pass a chain-link fence where a small 1936 cottage used to sit, next to a storefront still smelling of fresh paint, next to a coffee shop that didn't exist a year ago. For a street that has spent most of its life changing hands inside the same buildings rather than losing them, that's not a normal season. It's a structural one.

Marine Avenue is the commercial spine of Balboa Island, roughly two blocks of shops and restaurants that residents reach on foot, by bike, or off the ferry from the Peninsula. The lots here are small and old, and for decades the pattern has held: a restaurant closes, another one moves into the same shell, the awning changes, the address doesn't. What's happening on the street right now breaks that pattern in a way worth understanding if you live here, because it tells you something about what this stretch of the island is becoming, not just what's new to eat this week.

A building is actually coming down

At 224 Marine Avenue, the cottage-style structure that has stood since 1936 is being demolished to make way for Arc Balboa Island, a full-service restaurant from Marín Howarth von Blöm and chef Noah von Blöm, the team behind Arc Butcher & Baker and Arc Food & Libations in Costa Mesa. The project moved forward after a liquor license application was submitted, and construction is expected to wrap by the end of 2026.

The plan calls for outdoor-only seating on a 484-square-foot patio built around a two-story garden structure, with a menu built on approachable New American cooking and farm-to-table ingredients alongside a curated beer and wine program. That's a meaningfully different building than what's there now, not a tenant swap inside four existing walls.

That distinction matters on an island where the commercial footprint hasn't grown in generations. Marine Avenue doesn't have room to add square footage. When a building comes down here, something about the demand for space on this street has shifted enough to justify it.

The gelato shop that used to be a smoothie counter

A few doors down, at 226 Marine Avenue, Gelato del Mar is opening a second location in the space that most recently housed Toastique. The family-owned gelato shop, which already runs a popular storefront on Coast Highway in Corona del Mar, is currently open daily except Mondays and will mark the official opening with a celebration on Thursday, August 27, from 5 to 7 p.m., featuring a tasting of flavors that include a signature honeycomb gelato and the shop's well-known Pup Cup for dogs.

The opening will also lean on other Newport Beach names: Zay'z Artisanal Deli is providing house-made focaccia as a savory pairing, and Corona del Mar's WELL Alkaline Water will be pouring samples. A raffle for a custom-wrapped Balboa Island surfboard will benefit the Newport Beach Museum on Balboa Island, a donation-supported nonprofit that offers free admission and works to preserve the island's history.

According to the Newport Beach Independent, Gelato del Mar's Klebanoff said, "As Newport Beach residents, we believe in supporting the community that supports us." It's a small line, but it points to something real about who's opening on this street lately: a nearby operator adding a second location on the island.

An East Coast import moves in

At 329 Marine Avenue, Luke's Lobster has opened a Maine-style shack serving wild-caught lobster, crab, and shrimp rolls. The shop is running a National Lobster Day promotion on September 25 and 26, offering quarter-pound lobster rolls for 20 dollars.

Luke's Lobster isn't a local independent finding its footing. It's a recognizable regional name on a two-block retail strip on a residential island. That's worth sitting with if you've watched Marine Avenue's food mix stay mostly local and family-run for years, anchored by fixtures like the Balboa Bar and frozen banana stands that have defined the island's food identity since before most current residents moved in.

The coffee shop squeezed between two others

Marine Avenue's coffee scene had been stable for a long stretch, with Huskins Coffee holding down 229 Marine Avenue as one of the street's steadier fixtures. This year, Jasper Coffee opened at 327 Marine Avenue, a tight storefront that pairs espresso and matcha drinks with a small thrift shop and photo booth in the back, plus patio seating out front.

A new coffee concept opening within a couple hundred feet of an established one isn't a sign that the island suddenly needs more caffeine. It's a sign that a tenant was willing to bet on a small, expensive footprint on a street where square footage almost never opens up, and won.

What this adds up to right now

If you're walking Marine Avenue today, here's roughly where things stand:

  • 224 Marine Ave: the 1936 cottage is down or coming down, with Arc Balboa Island under construction and targeting a late 2026 finish.
  • 226 Marine Ave: Gelato del Mar is open daily except Mondays, with an official opening celebration on August 27.
  • 327 Marine Ave: Jasper Coffee is open, running alongside the island's longer-standing coffee spots.
  • 329 Marine Ave: Luke's Lobster is open, with a National Lobster Day promotion set for September 25 and 26.

None of this changes the basic rhythm of the island, which is still built around walking rather than driving, and the ferry ride, the Balboa Bars, and the frozen bananas that draw people across from the Peninsula haven't gone anywhere. What's changed is the appetite of outside operators to spend real money on a street where space has always been the limiting factor. A demolished cottage, a second location from a nearby gelato shop, and a national lobster-roll name all landing within the same stretch in the same year isn't coincidence. It's a signal that Marine Avenue's small footprint has become worth fighting for in a way it wasn't a few years ago.

For residents, that's mostly good news: more reasons to walk the two blocks, a wider mix of places to grab something before or after the ferry, and a street that's clearly still worth investing in. It's also a detail worth remembering the next time someone asks what's actually happening on the island, beyond the ferry line and the frozen bananas.

If you're weighing a move to Balboa Island or want a clearer read on what a specific block or building type is worth here, Justin Kuo has spent enough time on this stretch of Newport Beach to talk through it in plain terms. Reach out today.

Work With Justin

No matter what your real estate needs are, I’m here to help you move forward with confidence. My website offers the most current real estate information, and I’m always just a call or message away.

Follow Me on Instagram